Google Messages has suddenly gone haywire. After years of campaigning, the "seamless messaging" dream was finally realised, but it vanished as quickly as it arrived. Currently, the question is whether it has any prospect of ever returning.
Like a slow-motion train crash, Google quickly appreciated Apple for its long-awaited adoption of RCS, but as soon as it went live, it was criticised for its awkward security flaw. Despite iMessage's constant praise of its end-to-end encryption, those green bubbles are still without it.
Quick to react, Google and the GSMA said that end-to-end encryption for RCS is currently being developed. China comes along to ruin the fun, even though that might have won the day. Apple, Google, and other companies insist on end-to-end encryption since it appears that state-sponsored hackers have infiltrated US telco networks.
Cross-platform RCS has suffered severely as a result of the FBI and CISA are now both cautioning the public to utilise encrypted platforms properly. There is no security when texting from an Android phone to an iPhone, as Samsung has warned customers.
Google and the GSMA were quick to respond, promising that end-to-end encryption for RCS is in the works. But, although that might have won the day, China arrives to spoil the fun. It appears that state-sponsored hackers have broken into US telco networks, highlighting why Apple, Google, and others advocate for end-to-end encryption in the first place. With the FBI and CISA now warning citizens to use appropriately encrypted systems, cross-platform RCS has taken a significant knock. Even Samsung has advised consumers that texting from Android to iPhone is not secure.
Apple has never denied that iMessage is only secure within its own walled garden. Google, not Apple, pushed for cross-platform RCS. When it finally arrived with iOS 18, Google sent out public messages about non-blurry images and other new capabilities, whereas Apple said little, if anything at all.
So now it's up to Google Messages to pick up the pieces of this security catastrophe and figure out what to do next. How quickly can RCS be beefed up to meet the "responsible encryption" standard specified by the US government officials? Given the official warnings, how do Google and Apple encourage consumers to send basic RCS/SMS texts? How quickly will network confidence get better?
However, with timing being everything, the ultimate impediment to that RCS train could be Apple's upcoming iPhone update—iOS 18.2. To everyone's surprise, the iMaker has chosen to provide all of its users—not just those in controlled Europe—the ability to choose their default apps. For the first time, choose an over-the-top service like WhatsApp or Signal as your primary call and message provider.
The 2024 RCS dream has suffered a setback, though whether it has been buried beneath the waters remains to be seen. What is evident is that this benefits Meta, which owns the world's largest end-to-end encrypted messaging systems, WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger, even if they are not "responsibly" encrypted, as defined by the FBI, which requires authorised access to content when necessary.
Google Messages customers who use that platform to text friends, family, and colleagues will now require a new app. If you don't already have WhatsApp, Messenger, or Signal, you should download them right now. WhatsApp is the clear winner, striking the ideal combination between security, functionality, and scalability. Many of the people you communicate with will already have the app installed.
In keeping with the security theme, you must take two steps to guarantee the integrity of end-to-end encryption. Start by correctly configuring WhatsApp (or a substitute). This includes passkeys when they are available and two-factor authentication. Second, make sure you avoid taking any chances when installing apps, downloading files, or clicking links. It's as if you haven't secured your stuff at all if an attacker uses malware to take over your phone or lures you into installing malicious software, regardless of the messenger you use.
The irony for Google has continued with the announcement that Samsung is discontinuing RCS for millions of Galaxy users who are still using Samsung Messages and advising they migrate to Google Messages. The Galaxy maker told Verizon customers that "Samsung Messages will no longer support RCS after 1.6.2025." Switch to Google Messages to keep the more robust messaging you're accustomed to.”